So we made sure she didn't lose it, she finished getting ready for bed, and then she wrote another note to the tooth fairy. She made sure to mention the sugar plum topping again. :)
It says "Dear tooth fairy, My ^sweet^ tooth came out. Are you so happy to get it? Love, Riley P.S. I prefer to have a candy cane with sugar plum flavoring on top."
She made an envelope and put her note and her tooth in it and put it under her pillow. She was SO excited when she woke up the next morning and got a note back from her Tooth Fairy (Toothitrudy), who gave her a candy cane minus the sugar plum flavoring (she explained that Santa used it all up!), and a coin to put in her piggy bank.